Serving Those Who Serve Others

Experienced Insurance Professionals • Individualized Service • Risk Management Guidance• Superior Insurance Coverage

Insurance for Churches & Ministries

Bitner Henry Insurance Group insures over 6,000 Churches and Ministries.  As the nation’s largest independent agency representing Brotherhood Mutual, we understand the specific and unique needs of churches and related ministries.

We tailor policies that include insurance protection for Property, Liability, Vehicles, Workers’ Compensation, Cyber, Employee Practices, Security Teams and Religious Freedom.

Nonprofits & Social Services

We insure Nonprofits and social service organizations with coverage including Property, Liability, Worker’s Comp, Directors & Officers Liability, Abuse & Molestation Coverage and Commercial Umbrella.

Youth Services & Childcare

Our agency provides Property, Liability, and Vehicle insurance for youth service organizations including childcare facilities, camps, schools and clubs.

Recovery Programs

We serve Recovery Programs including Addiction Treatment Centers and Sober Homes.  These organizations can face unique risks that can quickly result in financial losses and damage to their reputations.

President Steve Henry with text 'We insure those who make a difference in the world.'
Headshot of Carol Henry with text 'Celebrating 30 Years with Carol Henry.'
Common Questions
What states do you insure?

Bitner Henry Insurance Group provides insurance products in 9 states including Delaware, Maryland, Pennsylvania,  Minnesota, North Carolina, Virginia, Georgia, Washington D.C. and West Virginia.

What insurance carriers do you represent?

We provide the highest quality insurance products from over 15 companies including Brotherhood Mutual, Safeco, Travelers, Mutual Benefit Group, Frederick Mutual, Chubb, Foremost Insurance Group, Hagerty, Progressive, Philadelphia, Donegal, Liberty Mutual, Markel, The Hartford, Chesapeake, Nationwide, and The Alliance of Nonprofits for Insurance.

What types of business do you insure?
Are your agents local?

Yes, our agents are assigned territories within driving distance and travel to client and prospective client locations.  We perform on-site surveys to accurately provide our carriers information about your facilities to insure the proper policy coverage.  We also believe in the value of face to face communications!

Sales Agent with text of 'Start your Insurance Career With Us. Now Hiring Sales Agents in Georgia, NC, and MD.'

Over the past five years, we have put Bitner-Henry to the test. In a series of unfortunate events it’s truly been a challenge. They stepped up and passed with flying colors.

– Walter McNeil

A place filled with high character insurance professionals.

– Gene McGuire

Their customer service people are great. Competitive offers haven’t come close to having us thinking of a change.

– Russell Craig

Customer Service Team

Sheila Shurtz

"It is satisfying to know that I have helped serve thousands of customers over the years."

Get to know Sheila Shurtz
Customer Service Agent
Woman on phone

File a Claim

Our team of experienced insurance professionals is available to assist you when filing a claim and are committed to guiding you through the process.

File a claim now

Woman with kids looking at computer

Manage Your Policy

Our goal is to make it easy and convenient for you to update and manage your policy. We provide a variety of online services to assist you.

Update your policy

Saleswoman talking with woman at desk

Career Opportunities

Are you passionate about helping others and looking for a new career opportunity? Many of our agents join us after successful sales or service careers in other industries.  However, we also recruit experienced insurance professionals.  Learn more about how to join our growing team of professionals!

See open positions