Brotherhood Mutual: Specialty Insurance for Virginia Ministries
Trusted Coverage Delivered Locally by Bitner Henry Insurance Group
Why Choose Bitner Henry Insurance Group for Your Church Insurance in Virginia?
- We serve thousands of ministries in the Mid-Atlantic, including the entire state of Virginia.
- You get an independent advocate. Starting your Quote with us means that you get to work with experienced agents who represent Brotherhood Mutual and other leading carriers.
- To ensure the most accurate protection and faithful stewardship of your resources, our sales agents commonly conduct on-site visits and building value reviews at your ministry. This allows us to personally understand your unique operations right from the start.
- Beyond your dedicated Sales Agent, our Support Team provides continuous licensed, professional support for service questions and claims assistance by phone and email.
- Get Assigned Immediately. Skip the wait and uncertainty of a forwarded submission from Brotherhood- when you submit here, a ministry insurance agent is immediately assigned to you, ready to start the conversation.
Start a Quote for Your Ministry Today!
Virginia Agents
Kyle Butler
Kyle Butler currently serves Virginia, including the sprawling Northern Virginia (NOVA) area, centered around large counties like Fairfax, Prince William, and Loudoun, plus the independent cities of Arlington and Alexandria. Moving southeast, he also targets the busy Hampton Roads metro area, a massive coastal and military hub. Here, his key markets are Virginia Beach (the biggest city), Chesapeake, Norfolk, and Newport News. The third major focus is the Greater Richmond Region, covering the state capital of Richmond City itself, and its fast-growing neighbors, Henrico and Chesterfield counties, which are vital for commerce and the state government. While these three regions are the core, he’ll also handle business in the significant, smaller regional hubs like Roanoke and Lynchburg to round out his statewide coverage.
He writes a monthly newsletter called the Launchpad specifically for Virginia schools. This free resource is specifically designed to help schools learn what they should know about their insurance, regional lawmaking, and how they can handle the regulations they are likely to encounter.
Nick Capobianco
Nick Capobianco currently serves Virginia schools, churches, nonprofits, businesses, and more. He helps serve the highly active areas surrounding the immediate DC suburbs, including the rapidly developing corridor that runs south from the Washington area, focusing on Stafford County and the growing independent city of Fredericksburg, which acts as a key commuter and military-affiliated hub. His territory swings west to capture the significant markets of the Shenandoah Valley, centered around the commercial and government base of Winchester City and its home, Frederick County, then down to the key college town of Harrisonburg in Rockingham County. He also works in scenic counties like Fauquier and Culpeper, serving clients who are a mix of long-time locals and affluent DC commuters seeking more space and a rural lifestyle.
Questions? We’re glad you asked.
Why work with us to find ministry insurance from Brotherhood Mutual or other carriers?
While a few other agencies in Virginia are able to provide Brotherhood quotes, Bitner Henry Insurance Group is one of the largest agencies in the state. Because of our size and experience working with Brotherhood, we hope to help you find the best results.
In addition, if a Brotherhood quote does not fit your needs, we also work with several other carriers and can help you find what’s right for you and your ministry.
What types of ministries do you insure?
We are an independent agency with agents in 9 states. We write policies for Churches, Nonprofits and Social Services, Daycare and Childcare Programs, Camps, Education, Sober Homes and Addiction Treatment Centers, International Programs, Small Business, Construction, and Personal lines.
Are your agents local?
Yes, our agents are assigned territories within driving distance and travel to client and prospective client locations. We perform on-site surveys to accurately provide our carriers information about your facilities to insure the proper policy coverage. We also believe in the value of face to face communications!








