Your School’s Liability When Responding to Cyberbullying

This Risk Insights is not intended to be exhaustive, nor should any discussion or opinions be construed as legal advice. Readers should contact legal counsel or an insurance professional for appropriate advice.

Your Liability When Responding to Cyberbullying

School administrators face a complex challenge when addressing cyberbullying: they are legally required to maintain a safe, non-hostile learning environment while simultaneously respecting students’ fundamental rights to free speech. Effectively navigating this intersection requires clear policy, careful consideration of context, and documented action.

1. Defining Your Legal Obligation and Liability

A school district’s liability often arises from negligence, which means failing to exercise a “reasonable standard of care” when officials have knowledge of a hostile environment.

• The Tinker Standard (Free Speech Limit): School officials can legally intervene in student speech (including off-campus online activity) only if it “would substantially interfere with the work of the school or impinge upon the rights of other students.”

  • Actionable Interference: This intervention is generally justifiable when the off-campus cyberbullying clearly “trolls back” into the school environment, causing fear, physical disruption, or material interference with school operations.

• Knowledge and Inaction: A district can be considered financially liable if officials with the authority to act have knowledge of cyberbullying that creates a hostile educational environment (especially on the basis of protected classes like race or sex) and fail to take reasonable steps to address it.

• School Property: When cyberbullying takes place using district-owned Internet systems, school-issued devices, or school computers, the school’s authority and liability concerns are immediately heightened.

2. Implementing a Proactive Anti-Cyberbullying Strategy

To mitigate liability, schools must demonstrate a proactive effort to address and prevent cyberbullying. This goes beyond simple response and involves a planned, systemic approach.

• Policy Development: Adopt and proactively enforce an official, board-approved anti-bullying and anti-cyberbullying policy. Ensure this policy defines cyberbullying, outlines expectations, and clearly states disciplinary actions.

• Internet Use Policy (AUP): Review and update your Acceptable Use Policy (AUP) to specifically address social media, off-campus online conduct that impacts the school environment, and consequences for misuse of school technology.

• Monitoring and Assessment:

  • Ensure adequate monitoring of student Internet use while on school property or using school devices.

  • Regularly assess the effectiveness of your anti-bullying program (e.g., using programs like the Olweus Bullying Prevention Program).

• Education and Communication: Educate all stakeholders—faculty, students, and parents—about the seriousness of cyberbullying, the relevant policies, and the procedures for reporting incidents.

3. Responding to an Incident: A Measured Approach

When an incident is reported, a quick, documented, and cautious response is required.

• Document Everything: Fully document the date, time, location (on or off-campus), specific content (screenshots), students involved, and the precise disruptive impact the speech had on the school environment or the victim’s rights.

• Seek Legal Counsel: Cyberbullying is a rapidly evolving legal area. School officials should always contact legal counsel to discuss the extent of their authority and liability regarding off-campus speech before taking formal disciplinary action.

• Prioritize Informal Resolution: Formal disciplinary action is not always the best first step and can sometimes provoke vicious retaliation. The recommended approach involves:

  • Parental Involvement: Involve the parents of the student who posted the material. Request that parents remove the harmful content immediately and monitor their child’s online activities to prevent escalation or retaliation.

  • Mediation/Counseling: Focus on providing counseling and conflict resolution support for both the victim and the aggressor (where appropriate and safe).

• Protect the Victim: The immediate priority is ensuring the victim feels safe and their learning environment is restored. This may involve temporary schedule changes or enhanced monitoring.

The most defensible position for any school is a thoroughly documented record showing officials had a proactive policy in place, received a report, and took reasonable, proportionate action to resolve the issue and protect students’ rights.

For more resources about bullying prevention, visit http://www.violencepreventionworks.org/ 

If you are in need of insurance for your home, business, international organization, home health organization, recovery program, ministry, or non-profit, feel free to request a quote! We would love to assist you with your insurance needs.