Brotherhood Mutual: Specialty Insurance for Pennsylvania Ministries
Trusted Coverage Delivered Locally by Bitner Henry Insurance
Why Choose Bitner Henry Insurance Group for Your Church Insurance in Pennsylvania?
- We serve thousands of ministries in the Mid-Atlantic, including the entire state of Pennsylvania.
- You get an independent advocate. Starting your Quote with us means that you get to work with experienced agents who represent Brotherhood Mutual and other leading carriers.
- To ensure the most accurate protection and faithful stewardship of your resources, our sales agents commonly conduct on-site visits and building value reviews at your ministry. This allows us to personally understand your unique operations right from the start.
- Beyond your dedicated Sales Agent, our Support Team provides continuous licensed, professional support for service questions and claims assistance by phone and email.
- Get Assigned Immediately. Skip the wait and uncertainty of a direct submission—when you submit here, a ministry insurance agent is immediately assigned to you, ready to start the conversation.
Start a Quote for Your Ministry Today!
Pennsylvania Agents
Lucas Payson
Lucas Payson serves ministries across all of Southern Pennsylvania, specializing in the diverse commercial landscape stretching from the Allegheny Mountains to the Delaware River. His extensive service area covers the entire Harrisburg-York-Lancaster region (including the state capital, Harrisburg), the high-growth Philadelphia Metro Area (including Chester and Montgomery counties), the business hubs of the Lehigh Valley (Allentown and Bethlehem), and the manufacturing and logistics centers along the southern border (York, Adams, and Franklin counties).
Nick Capobianco
Nick Capobianco also helps serve churches, non-profits, and ministries across all of York County, Pennsylvania. His focus area encompasses the entire county, from the metropolitan hub of the City of York to the major commercial corridor along I-83.
This includes the key business districts around Hanover, the growing northern suburbs of Dover and Manchester, the southern communities along the Mason-Dixon line like Shrewsbury and New Freedom, and the historic towns along the Susquehanna River like Wrightsville.
Andrew Henry
Andrew Henry helps serve all of York County. His coverage extends beyond the City of York to include key commercial hubs like Hanover and Dillsburg, the logistics and industrial areas around Newberrytown and Jacobus, and the rapidly growing residential and small business sectors in towns such as Red Lion and Gettysburg Pike. He also serves Southeastern Pennsylvania, including Lebanon, Chester, and Philadelphia Counties.
Joel Henry
Joel Henry serves Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Fayette, Greene, Indiana, Lawrence, Washington, and Westmoreland counties. From the bustling metropolitan center of Pittsburgh itself, the surrounding business hubs of Cranberry, Monroeville, and Washington, the college town of Indiana, and the historic coal-country cities like Uniontown, to the growing industrial and rural communities in the Ohio Valley and Laurel Highlands region, Joel aims to serve ministries and organizations in Southwestern Pennsylvania.
Questions? We’re glad you asked.
Why work with us to find ministry insurance from Brotherhood Mutual or other carriers?
While a few other agencies in Pennsylvania are able to provide Brotherhood quotes, Bitner Henry Insurance Group is the one of the largest agencies in the state. Because of our size and experience working with Brotherhood, we hope to help you find the best results.
In addition, if a Brotherhood quote does not fit your needs, we also work with several other carriers and can help you find what’s right for you and your ministry.
What types of ministries do you insure?
We are an independent agency with agents in 9 states. We write policies for Churches, Nonprofits and Social Services, Daycare and Childcare Programs, Camps, Education, Sober Homes and Addiction Treatment Centers, International Programs, Small Business, Construction, and Personal lines.
Are your agents local?
Yes, our agents are assigned territories within driving distance and travel to client and prospective client locations. We perform on-site surveys to accurately provide our carriers information about your facilities to insure the proper policy coverage. We also believe in the value of face-to-face communications.
